DISCUSSION DRAFT S.L.C.
108TH CONGRESS
1ST SESSION
IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
Mrs. FEINSTEIN (for herself and Mr. KERRY) introduced the following
bill;
which was read twice and referred to the Committee on (____)
A BILL
To prevent the slaughter of horses in and from the United States for
human consumption by prohibiting the slaughter of horses for human
consumption and by prohibiting the trade and transport of horseflesh
and live horses intended for human consumption, and for other purposes.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled,
SECTION 1. FINDINGS.
Congress finds that
- horses have played a significant role in the history and culture
of the United States;
- horses in the United States are not raised for food or fiber;
- as a nonfood and recreational animal, horses should be protected
from slaughter for human consumption;
- the foreign-owned horse slaughter industry has slaughtered and
exported for human consumption over 3,000,000 American horses
in the last 2 decades;
- (A) approximately 55,000 American horses are slaughtered for
human consumption annually in the United States by foreign-owned
slaughterhouses; and
(B) tens of thousands of live horses are exported from the United
States annually for slaughter for human consumption;
- horses slaughtered for human consumption in foreign-owned plants
in the United States have often been hauled several thousand miles
over several days, contrary to acceptable nonslaughter standards
for water, food, and rest;
- (A) many horses sent to be slaughtered for human consumption
are young, healthy animals;
(B) other horses are old, sick, blind, crippled, and in otherwise
poor condition and are unfit to withstand the rigors of long travel;
and
(C) horses sent to be slaughtered for human consumption are often
(i) shipped on crowded double-deck trucks designed for shorter-necked
species such as pigs, cattle, and sheep; and
(ii) forced to travel in a bent position, which can result in
suffering, injury, and death;
- (A) horses killed at foreign-owned slaughter-houses are not
killed by the preferable method of chemical euthanasia but instead
often endure repeated blows to the head with stunning equipment
that often does not render the animals unconscious; and
(B) some horses proceed still conscious through the remaining
stages of slaughter for human consumption, consisting of being
bled out and dismembered;
- because horses in the United States are not food animals, veterinarians
commonly prescribe and treat horses with potent drugs that may
reside in the horseflesh and be dangerous when consumed by humans;
because of the lack of disclosure on the part of the agents and
dealers for foreign-owned slaughterhouses
- (A) horses are often acquired and slaugtered for human consumption
through fraud and misrepresentation; and
(B) slaughter for human consumption provides a quick and evidence-free
outlet for stolen horses; and the imposition of a ban on the sale
of horseflesh for human consumption, regardless of the source
of the horseflesh, is consistent with
- (A) the international obligations of the United States because
such a ban
(i) applies equally to domestic and foreign producers; and
(ii) avoids any discrimination among foreign sources of competing
products; and
(B) provisions of international agreements to which the United
States is a party that expressly allow for measures designed
(i) to protect the health and welfare of animals; and
(ii) to enjoin the use of deceptive trade practices in international
or domestic commerce.
SEC. 2. PURPOSES.
The purposes of this Act are
- to prohibit the slaughter of horses for human consumption;
- to prohibit the sale, possession, and trade of horseflesh for
human consumption; and
- to prohibit the sale, possession, and trade of horses for slaughter
for human consumption.
SEC. 3. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
- EUTHANASIA.The term euthanasia
means the killing of an animal humanely by a means that
(A) immediately renders the animal unconscious; and
(B) causes the animal to remain unconscious until the animal dies.
- EXPORT.The term export means to
take from any area subject to the jurisdiction of the United States
to an area not subject to that jurisdiction, regardless of whether
the taking constitutes an exportation within the meaning of the
customs laws of the United States.
- HORSE.
(A) IN GENERAL.The term horse means
any member of the family Equidae.
(B) INCLUSIONS.The term horse includes
a horse, pony, donkey, mule, ass, or burro.
- HORSEFLESH.The term horseflesh
means the flesh of a dead horse, including the viscera, skin,
hair, hide, hooves, and bones of a dead horse.
- HORSE RESCUE FACILITY.The term horse rescue
facility means a facility described in section 6(a)(1).
- HUMAN CONSUMPTION.The term human consumption
means ingestion by human beings as a source of food.
- IMPORT.The term import means to
bring into any area subject to the jurisdiction of the United
States from an area not subject to that jurisdiction, regardless
of whether the bringing constitutes an importation within the
meaning of the customs laws of the United States.
- PERSON.The term person means
(A) an individual, corporation, partnership, trust, association,
or other private entity;
(B) an officer, employee, agent, department, or instrumentality
of
(i) the Federal Government; or
(ii) any State, municipality, or political subdivision of State;
or
(C) any other entity subject to the jurisdiction of the United
States.
- SECRETARY.The term Secretary means
the Secretary of Agriculture.
- SLAUGHTER.The term slaughter means
the commercial slaughter of 1 or more horses with the intent to
sell, barter, or trade the flesh for human consumption.
- STATE.The term State means
(A) a State;
(B) the District of Columbia;
(C) the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico;
(D) the Virgin Islands;
(E) Guam;
(F) the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands;
(G) American Samoa; and
(H) any other territory or possession of the United States.
- TRANSPORT.The term transport means
(A) to move by any means; or
(B) to receive or load onto a vehicle for the purpose of movement.
- UNITED STATES.The term United States
has the meaning given the term customs territory of
the United States in general note 2 of the Harmonized
Tariff Schedule of the United States.
SEC. 4. PROHIBITED ACTS.
A person shall not
- slaughter a horse for human consumption;
- import into, or export from, the United States horseflesh for
human consumption or live horses intended for slaughter for human
consumption;
- sell or barter, offer to sell or barter, purchase, possess,
transport, deliver, or receive horseflesh for human consumption
or live horses intended for slaughter for human consumption; or
solicit, request, or otherwise knowingly cause any act prohibited
under paragraph (1), (2), or (3).
SEC. 5. PENALTIES AND ENFORCEMENT.
(a) CRIMINAL PENALTIES.A person violates section 4 shall be
imprisoned not more than 1 year, fined under title 18, United States
Code, or both.
(b) CIVIL PENALTIES.
- IN GENERAL.If a person violates section 4, in addition
to any other civil or criminal penalty that may be imposed under
title 18, United States Code, or any other provision of law, the
Secretary shall
(A) assess against the person a civil penalty of not less than
$2,500 nor more than $5,000; and
(B) seize all horses that are
(i) in the physical or legal possession of the person at the time
of arrest of the person; and
(ii) intended for slaughter for human consumption.
- DEBARMENT.The Secretary shall prohibit a person from importing,
exporting, transporting, trading, or selling horses in the United
States, if the Secretary finds that the person has engaged in
a pattern or practice of actions that has resulted in a final
judicial or administrative determination with respect to the assessment
of a criminal or civil penalty for a violation of this Act.
- REMISSION OR MITIGATION.For good cause shown, the Secretary
may remit or mitigate any civil penalty imposed under this subsection.
(c) SEPARATE OFFENSES. For the purposes of this section, the
following shall constitute a separate offense:
- Each live horse transported, traded, slaughtered, or possessed
in violation of this Act.
- Each 400 pounds or less of seized horseflesh.
(d) NOTICE; HEARING.No monetary penalty may be assessed under
this section against a person for a violation of section 4 unless
the person is given notice and opportunity for a hearing with respect
to the violation in accordance with section 554 of title 5, United
States Code.
(e) ENFORCEMENT.
- USE OF PERSONNEL. The Secretary
(A) shall enforce this Act; and
(B) may use, by agreement, the personnel, services, and facilities
of any Federal, State, or local agency for the purpose of enforcing
this Act.
- EXECUTION OF PROCESS; ARREST; SEIZURE.
Any person authorized by the Secretary to enforce this Act may,
in addition to any other authority conferred by law
(A) execute any warrant or process issued by any officer or court
of competent jurisdiction to enforce this Act;
(B) with or without warrant or other process, arrest any person
that commits in the presence or view of the authorized person
a violation of this Act (including any regulation promulgated
under this Act);
(C) seize any horse or horseflesh possessed or being transported
in violation of this Act (including any regulation promulgated
under this Act) and dispose of the horse or horseflesh, in accordance
with this section and regulations promulgated by the Secretary;
or
(D) seize any vehicle or other equipment that was used (or appears
to have been used) in violation of this Act (including any regulation
promulgated under this Act) (unless the owner of the vehicle or
other equipment did not know or did not have reason to know that
the vehicle or other equipment was being used in violation of
this Act).
SEC. 6. CARE OF SEIZED HORSES.
(a) PLACEMENT OF SEIZED HORSES.
- TEMPORARY PLACEMENT.
(A) TAX-EXEMPT ANIMAL RESCUE FACILITIES. After seizure of
a live horse in accordance with this Act, during the period in
which the criminal or civil action against the person charged
with violating this Act is pending, the arresting authority shall
work with any appropriate animal welfare society or animal control
department to provide for the temporary placement of the horse
with an animal rescue facility that is
(i) an organization described in section 501(c)(3) of the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986; and
(ii) exempt from taxation under section 501(a) of that Code.
(B) OTHER ANIMAL RESCUE FACILITIES. If placement at a facility
described in subparagraph (A) is not practicable, the arresting
authority shall work with any appropriate animal welfare society
or animal control department to place the horse temporarily with
(i) a facility that has as its primary purpose the humane treatment
of animals; or
(ii) another suitable facility.
- BONDS.
(A) POSTING OF BOND. The owner of a horse seized in accordance
with this Act may prevent permanent placement of the horse by
the horse rescue facility that has temporary custody of the horse
by posting with the court, not later than 10 days after the date
on which the horse is seized, a bond in such amount as the court
determines to be sufficient to provide for the necessary care
and keeping of the horse for not less than 60 days, including
the day on which the horse was taken into custody.
(B) POSTING OF NEW BOND. If the horse has not been returned
to the owner by the end of the time for which expenses are covered
by the bond posted under subparagraph (A), and, if the owner desires
to prevent permanent placement of the horse by the custodial horse
rescue facility, the owner shall post a new bond with the court
not later than 10 days after the date of expiration of the prior
bond.
(C) COSTS FOR PROVIDING CARE FOR HORSE DEDUCTED FROM BOND.
If a bond has been posted in accordance with subparagraph (A)
or (B), the custodial horse rescue facility may draw from the
bond the actual reasonable costs incurred by the horse rescue
facility in providing the necessary care and keeping of the seized
horse during the period beginning on the date of the initial seizure
and ending on the date of final disposition of the horse in the
criminal or civil action alleging a violation of this Act.
- PERMANENT PLACEMENT. Except as provided in subsection
(b), any horse seized under this Act and not returned to the owner
shall be placed permanently with a horse rescue facility on
(A) the imposition on the owner of the horse of a penalty under
this Act;
(B) the surrender of the horse by the owner;
(C) the failure of the owner to post a bond in accordance with
paragraph (2); or
(D) the determination by the Secretary that the owner cannot be
identified.
(b) EUTHANASIA OF SEIZED HORSES.
- EMERGENCY CIRCUMSTANCES.
(A) IN GENERAL.The Secretary or any law enforcement individual
enforcing this Act may order or perform the immediate euthanasia
of any horse seized under this Act if the horse is injured beyond
recovery and suffering irreversibly.
(B) METHODS.The method of euthanasia under subparagraph
(A)
(i) shall be in accordance with the report of the Panel on Euthanasia
of the American Veterinary Medical Association, dated 2000, and
State and local laws; but
(ii) shall not include electrocution or penetrating captive bolt.
- HORSES BEYOND RECOVERY OR NOT PLACEABLE.
(A) IN GENERAL. The Secretary or any individual charged
with enforcing this Act may order euthanasia of any horse seized
under this Act
(i) that is injured, disabled, or diseased beyond recovery; or
(ii) the placement of which at a horse rescue facility is not
practicable within 90 days of any circumstance described in subsection
(a)(3).
(B) METHODS. The method of euthanasia under subparagraph
(A)
(i) shall consist of performance by an equine or large-animal
veterinarian of the euthanasia rated Acceptable
for horses in the report of the Panel on Euthanasia of the American
Veterinary Medical Association, dated 2000; but
(ii) shall not include penetrating captive bolt, electrocution,
gunshot, or other nonchemical means.
SEC. 7. FUNDING FOR CARE OF SEIZED HORSES.
(a) GRANTS TO HORSE RESCUE FACILITIES. To the extent that
funds are made available by appropriation Acts, the Secretary shall
make grants to horse rescue facilities that give adequate assurances
to the Secretary that the horse rescue facility is willing to accept
horses seized in accordance with this Act.
(b) PENALTIES, FINES, AND FORFEITED PROPERTY. Amounts received
as penalties, as fines, or from the sale of forfeited property under
this Act shall be used for the care of any live horse that is
- seized from a person that violates this Act; and
- taken into the possession of the United States or placed with
a horse rescue facility.
SEC. 8. REPORT ON ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS.
Not later than 2 years after the date of enactment of this Act and
annually thereafter, the Secretary shall submit to Congress a report
that
- describes the efforts of the United States Government to enforce
this Act; and
- assesses the adequacy of the resources available for such enforcement.
SEC. 9. EXEMPTIONS.
(a) IN GENERAL. Except as provided in section 4, 10 nothing
in this Act affects the regulation by any State of horses in the
State.
(b) EXCEPTION FOR DESIGNATED LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL PURPOSES.
A person described in section 3(8)(B) may engage in an activity
described in paragraph (2), (3), or (4) of section 4 solely for
the purpose of enforcing this Act.
SEC. 10. EFFECTIVE DATE.
This Act takes effect on the date that is 1 year after the date
of enactment of this Act.
"Keep America's horses in the stable and off the table!"
E-mail HOOFPAC
Copyright © 2002 - HOOFPAC Political Action Committee - All rights reserved.
|